By Tom Scalisi | Updated Mar 3, 2022 1:01 PM

BobVila.com and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.

North America is home to 3,000 species of spiders. The vast majority of these arachnids are not dangerous, more of a nuisance than reason for fear. However, limited species, among them brown recluse spiders and black widow spiders, can cause real harm (though bites are rarely fatal).

Between inducing fear or annoyance, dealing with an infestation, or keeping dangerous local species at bay—a DIY pest control program may be all that’s necessary. The best spider killer contains potent chemical or natural compounds. These formulas are great for repelling or killing spiders and continue to work days, weeks, or months after application.

Keep reading to learn about insecticide spray, dust, glue traps, and natural insect repellents. With the shopping considerations below, choose the most suitable product among these effective solutions for insect control.

Pest control companies market a variety of products to control spider and spider mite issues. While most products work, some may be better suited for your needs than others. The best spider sprays, dust, and glue traps work in different ways but all serve the same purpose—for repelling or killing spiders.

Chemical-based insecticide dusts are ideal for killing bugs on their way into your home. These powders contain bifenthrin, permethrin, cyfluthrin, beta-cyfluthrin, deltamethrin, cypermethrin, or lambda-cyhalothrin. The compounds contained in the pesticides either compromise the spider’s nervous system or exoskeleton. They typically work within 24 hours, offering one of the quickest means of controlling spiders. Most manufacturers specify that the products last at least 2-3 years.

Since pesticide dusts are toxic, they should be sprinkled where no children or pets will get to them. They’re suitable for long-term solutions for under cabinets and along basement walls. If anyone in your household gets chemical insecticide in their eyes or mouth, contact Poison Control immediately for instructions on how to proceed.

Natural spider killers for both indoors and outdoors is diatomaceous earth. This compound contains fossilized aquatic organisms, available in dust (powder) form. Diatomaceous earth causes insects to dry out and die by absorbing oils and fats from their exoskeleton. This versatile, non-toxic product exterminates spiders and other insects including bed bugs, cockroaches, fleas, and ants.

The natural dust starts to work within 48 hours, and since the compound does not break down, it’s effective as long as it stays dry. Spread diatomaceous earth in a thin layer around plants, on the lawn, or anywhere else you want to get rid of spiders. While this product is considered safe, be careful during application, as it can irritate the skin and eyes.

There are several types of spray containers for killing spiders, including aerosol cans, liquid spray bottles, and large jugs that connect to garden hose nozzles. Chemical sprays contain the synthetic compounds that are sometimes present in dust pesticides. Some are available as concentrates that you dilute and apply using a spray bottle.

Chemical spider spray disrupts an insect’s central nervous system and kills them instantly. You can use sprays for the exterior of the home to create a barrier to keep bugs out, or as spot treatments when you see a crawling bug or two. Aerosol sprays make covering a lot of ground quick and easy. While spraying, it’s important to maintain 12 inches of space between the nozzle and the treated surface.

The downside is that they’re one of the costlier products, and you might need a few cans to spray large areas, like your home’s foundation. It’s also worth noting that oil-based aerosols are chemical-heavy, and can leave a greasy residue behind.

Spray bottles are usually lightweight and reusable. If you use the entire contents of the bottle, you can reuse it by filling it with a water-soluble pesticide. The only negative aspect of using spray bottles is that they can cause hand or arm fatigue when spraying large areas.

Natural pest control concentrates and sprays repel spiders without the use of chemicals or other potentially harmful ingredients. These products offer a safer option for indoor use, particularly in households with young children or curious pets.

Natural repellents deter spiders using plants and compounds that are unpleasant to their senses; the same products have a pleasing or neutral smell to humans. Formulas containing peppermint essential oil are among the most popular, since they leave the home smelling fresh. Vinegar-based products are also effective, and many can double as household cleaners.

Natural spider repellents are usually applied by spraying hiding places for insects, like cracks and crawl spaces. Natural spider killers do not kill spiders, and their effects last for days instead of weeks or months, like chemical-based products.

Another safe means of controlling crawling pests in the home is by using traps. Traps have sticky surfaces that catch bugs and hold them in place until they die. The best options fold up to keep pets and children from touching the sticky surface.

The added benefit of folding traps is that you don’t have to look at a pile of dead bugs on the floor—and they’re also less disgusting to pick up and throw away. Place them along walls and baseboards where bugs are likely to travel.

Given the variety of natural and chemical-based products, there are numerous options available. These insect solutions are among the best in their categories and help you win the war against eight-legged pests.

Black Flag’s Spider and Scorpion Killer Aerosol Spray is the real deal when it comes to DIY pest control. This super potent spray paralyzes and kills spiders of all kinds. Using a combination of prallethrin and lambda-cyhalothrin, it can handle tough-to-kill species, such as black widow, brown recluse, and wolf spiders.

Spraying this Black Flag spider killer in your home will protect it from these creepiest of crawlies for up to 16 weeks. You can unleash Black Flag’s aerosol spray from 5 feet away to kill spiders even as they hatch. The long-range spray is perfect for those who fear going face to face with the arachnid enemy.

For those on a budget, TERRO offers a low-cost solution with their Spider Killer Aerosol Spray. The versatile spray combines pyrethrins and deltamethrin that combats many types of crawling bugs, including spiders, ants, and cockroaches.

Use it on a single insect, as a foundation spray, or for treating cracks and crevices. As a barrier treatment or crevice spray, TERRO’s spray needs reapplying every 4 weeks, so it doesn’t last quite as long as the other best spider sprays on our list.

If you’re determined to keep spiders out of your home, then Wet & Forget’s Miss Muffet’s Revenge Spider Killer is a solid option. The formula contains Bifenthrin and comes in a half-gallon bottle with a spray distance of up to 12 feet.

This chemical spider killer is ideal for spraying the surfaces outside of your home where spiders are likely to hang out. It works for up to 12 months, so one application a year should be enough to keep your home spider-free.

For those looking to end their spider problem without introducing harmful chemicals in the environment, diatomaceous earth is a solid option.

This natural substance consists of the fossilized remains of microscopic aquatic organisms; it infiltrates the exoskeletons of ants, dehydrating them from the inside out and killing them within 48 hours.

Diatomaceous earth is also an effective means of killing bedbugs, cockroaches, fleas, and other insects. This product is not harmful to humans or pets, providing the ideal pest solution for homes with pets and young children.

The Delta Dust bottle may not be flashy—but this product is no less effective. Delta Dust is a powerful bug barrier containing deltamethrin, which kills insects when they eat it or come in contact with it.

The duster bottle is well-suited to squeezing under appliances or into cracks and crevices in a foundation. This 1 lbs. bottle can protect over 2000 sq. ft. of space and is completely waterproof and non-clumping.

Since Delta Dust needs to remain on the surface that you apply it to, this product can have a low-level toxic effect if eaten or inhaled by people. While not a significant concern, it’s something to keep in mind.

If you’re looking for a safe, plant-based way to repel spiders, spider mites, and insects, Mighty Mint Spider Repellent is one of the best products available. This highly concentrated recipe uses peppermint essential oil to repel spiders. It’s safe for use both inside and out, as well as completely safe around pets and children.

Spray it around the exterior of your home or any space inside the home you’d like to be free of insect troubles. This spray is only effective for 2-3 days, so if this is your only defense against arachnid invaders, you may end up pumping a lot of peppermint to keep your home bug-free.

If you’re aiming to treat your curtains, carpet, or furniture to help reduce the spider population in your home, this 2-pack from Harris is the go-to on the list.

Harris Spider Killer Liquid Spray contains a non-staining deltamethrin formula. It’s perfect for spraying fabrics and carpet and it works on solid surfaces as well. Simply spray the area you’d like to treat and allow to dry. It’s safe for use both inside and outside of the home.

Something to keep in mind is that this product is a treatment, not a contact killer, and the spray needs to dry before it’s capable of killing bugs. Once it’s dry, it’s safe for children and pets.

The TERRO Spider and Insect trap is a classic design with a modern twist. This sticky trap catches bugs as they walk across the surface and keeps them there until they die. You can lay these traps flat against a wall or slide them under furniture and appliances. They also fold up into a box-type design to hide the unsightly bugs that die inside.

These traps are easy to throw out, replace, and offer a great alternative to toxic chemicals or messy sprays. For these traps to be effective, spiders and other bugs need to walk through them. They don’t work like bait. Bugs that decide to walk around these traps will live to see another day.

Spiders in the home may be more noticeable—but outdoor infestations are nonetheless bothersome, especially if you spend a lot of time in your yard. Common spider residents to lawns and landscapes are grass, hobo, and wolf spiders, the latter having a fairly dangerous bite.

With bifenthrin and zeta-cypermethrin as the active ingredients, this Ortho BugClear lawn spray can handle spiders in grass, gardens, and shrubbery. The two active ingredients kill affected ants by slowly shutting down the nervous system to function properly.

This chemical spider spray is a versatile product that can also work against spiders, ticks, mosquitoes, fleas, spiders, and more than 200 additional insect species. The solution comes in a ready-to-use spray bottle that connects to your garden hose, containing enough solution to treat a lawn infestation for up to 6 months.

Between concentrates, sprays, dust, and traps, natural and chemical spider control products are plentiful. The right spider killer or repellent depends on your household, affected areas, and the extent of the problem. While natural formulas are safer, they don’t last as long as their chemical counterparts like the Black Flag and TARRO sprays and must be reapplied more often.

When opting for DIY pest control, it’s important to follow manufacturer guidelines and handle products with caution. Store and apply insecticides inside where children and pets won’t come in contact with them. In particular, make use of application distances when using sprays and avoid direct skin contact with all insecticides.

After thorough evaluation of the key aspects that should be included in the best spider killers including versatility, type, quantity, and effectiveness, our top picks can provide successful removal of many household and outdoor pests.

Many of the above options offer quick and long-lasting results that can also kill other common insects such as cockroaches, fleas, crickets, and scorpions for full pest removal. Plus, some of these options are non-toxic or humane for less chemicals in your home or outdoor spaces for the safety of pets and children.

Finally, many of the best spider killers above also come in budget-friendly, large quantity options or 2-packs for long-lasting use in the event of re-infestation. However, many of our picks were chemical-based solutions and directions should always be followed for safety.

If you’re new to DIY extermination, you may want to consult these commonly asked questions about spider killers. If you have additional questions, contact the manufacturer of the product you purchase.

Peppermint essential oil and vinegar are natural, safer alternatives to chemical spider repellents. However, natural repellents do not last as long. Mighty Mint peppermint oil is a potent and pleasant smelling spray that effectively repels spiders for 2-3 days.

You can spot-spray a single spider, or treat your foundation, windows, doors, and other places the insects gather, like cracks, crevices, and crawl spaces.

Natural spider sprays containing peppermint oil or vinegar are very safe. When stored correctly, chemical insecticides are safe. Precautions for storing insecticide spray include:

To safely dispose of an empty bottle of spider spray, rinse the exterior of the container and cap over the sprayer. Dispose of the cap as you would regular household waste and dispose or recycle the container based on material. All aerosol cans can be recycled once empty.

Unused insecticides should never be poured into sinks, drains, or toilets. This can contaminate local waterways, as well as harm wildlife. According to the Environmental Protection Agency, pesticides cannot be eliminated from most municipal drinking water.

To dispose of pesticides, follow the instructions on the product label. These are usually indicated in a “Storage and Disposal” statement on the product label.

Treat the exterior of your home according to the manufacturer’s suggestions. The label should have a treatment interval listed, so adhere to it when you’re putting together your DIY pest control plan.

Disclosure: BobVila.com participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for publishers to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Copyright © 2022 Acton Media Inc. All rights reserved.